Stephen Hawking's black hole information paradox is a direct collision between the two pillars of modern physics. Quantum mechanics insists, through the principle of unitarity, that information can never be destroyed. General relativity, applied to black holes, seems to insist the opposite: when a black hole evaporates away through Hawking radiation, everything that fell in appears to be erased from the universe. One of these two descriptions must give, and physicists have spent five decades arguing over which.

The paradox matters because it is not a puzzle about exotic objects at the edge of the cosmos; it is a stress test of the theories themselves. As the physicist Netta Engelhardt puts it in a feature for MIT's physics department, "the black hole information paradox is a conflict between two apparently incontrovertible facts: first, that semiclassical gravity is valid on scales where gravitational and quantum effects are more or less separate; second, that quantum mechanics is 'unitary' and thus all quantum processes are in principle, though not necessarily in practice, reversible."