Fuzzballs, Firewalls, and Complementarity: Mechanisms for Information Preservation
The fuzzball proposal, developed within the string theory community, redefines the black hole itself. Instead of an empty region of spacetime surrounding a singularity, a fuzzball is a ball of strings and stringy matter extending out to what would classically be the horizon. There is no empty interior and no sharp horizon to fall through. In this picture, information is encoded in the quantum correlations of the Hawking radiation, which is not precisely thermal, and the information never truly crosses an event horizon to be lost, because the black hole is a quantum object from its surface inward. The mechanism avoids information loss by redefining the nature of the black hole's interior.
The firewall proposal grew out of Samir Mathur's argument that small corrections to Hawking's calculation are insufficient to resolve the paradox. As summarized in the Wikipedia article on the paradox, the operational difference between the two proposals is what an observer crossing the horizon encounters: high-energy matter, as the firewall proposal suggests, or merely low-energy structure, as the fuzzball proposal suggests. Both proposals have been questioned for lacking an appropriate mechanism that can generate structure at the horizon scale, a criticism that keeps them contested rather than settled.
Black hole complementarity takes a different route entirely, one modeled on how quantum mechanics already handles complementary properties. It suggests that infalling information would be cloned, with one copy falling into the black hole and one copy escaping as Hawking radiation. An observer falling in sees information pass the horizon; an outside observer sees it reflected or re-emitted. The concept holds that different observers experience different realities regarding information, and that no single observer ever witnesses information destruction. The catch, as the same summary notes, is that cloning would seem to violate the no-cloning theorem of quantum mechanics, which states that information cannot be cloned. Complementarity's defenders argue the two copies are never observable together, so no contradiction can ever be demonstrated, but the proposal remains a logical tightrope rather than a derivation.